Joey Fatone and Kelly Baldwin

In case you forgot, singer Joey Fatone rose to prominence as a member of the ’90s boy band NSYNC. Most recently, fans saw him on the show Dancing with the Stars. A few years before that, in 2004, Fatone married his high school sweetheart Kelly Baldwin in a ceremony attended by every NSYNC member, including Justin Timberlake. Today, the pair has two daughters, Briahna Joel and Kloey Alexandria.

Although the pair married in 2004, Fatone sadly submitted separation papers in 2020. He then appeared on the red carpet with his new girlfriend, Izabel Araujo. When Baldwin was asked for a comment, she simply replied, “I don’t really want to talk about this.”